Newsroom  •  Site Map  •  Contact NERC

  
Advanced Search
 
About NERC Standards Compliance Assessments Events Analysis Programs  

 

Project 2007-12
Frequency Response

Related Files

Status: 
BAL-003-1 was posted for a parallel 45-day formal comment period and initial ballot and non-binding poll through December 9, 2011. 
The initial ballot failed to achieve a two-thirds industry approval.  The SDT is reviewing comments received during the initial ballot and modifying the standard and associated documents.  The proposed standard is scheduled to be posted for a parallel 30-day comment and 10-day ballot beginning February 21, 2012.  

Purpose/Industry Need:
Frequency Response, a measure of an Interconnection’s ability to stabilize frequency immediately following the sudden loss of generation or load, is a critical component to the reliable operation of the bulk power system, particularly during disturbances and restoration.  The proposed standard’s intent is to collect data needed to accurately model existing Frequency Response.  There is evidence of continuing decline in Frequency Response in the three Interconnections over the past 10 years, but no confirmed reason for the apparent decline.  The proposed standard requires entities to provide data so that Frequency Response in each of the Interconnections can be modeled, and the reasons for the decline in Frequency Response can be identified.  Once the reasons for the decline in Frequency Response are confirmed, requirements can be written to control Frequency Response to within defined reliability parameters.

 Draft Action Dates Results Consideration of Comments

Draft 2

BAL-003-1
Clean | Redline to Last Posting

Attachment A
Clean

Attachment B
Clean

Implementation Plan
Clean | Redline to Last Posting

Supporting Materials:

Background Document

BAL-003-0.1b

Comment Form (Word)

Mapping Document

FRS Form 1:

Eastern Interconnection

ERCOT

Quebec Interconnection

Western Interconnection

FRS Form 2 for Interconnection with Multiple BAs:

Two-second Sample Data

Three-second Sample Data

Four-second Sample Data

Five-second Sample Data

Six-second Sample Data

FRS Form 2 for Interconnection wit One BA:

Two-second Sample Data

Three-second Sample Data




Initial Ballot and Non-Binding Poll of VRFs and VSLs

Vote>>

Info>>
11/30/11 - 12/09/11
(closed)
Summary>>

Full Record>>

Non-Binding Poll Results>>
 
Formal Comment Period

Info>>

Submit Comments>>
10/25/11 - 12/09/11
(closed)
Comments Received>>  
Join Ballot Pool
Initial and Non-Binding

Info>>

Join>>
10/25/11 - 11/23/11
(closed)
   

Draft 1

BAL-003-1

Clean

Attachment A

 

Supporting Materials:

BAL-003-0

Supplemental SAR

FRS Form 1 Instructions

FRS Form 1

Implementation Plan

Comment Form (Word)

Field Test

Formal Comment Period



              Info>>


Submit Comments>>
02/04/11 – 03/07/11 Comments Received>> Consideration of Comments>>

Final SAR Version 3

Standard Drafting Team Nominations

Info>>

Submit Nomination>>

07/17/07 - 07/30/07

(closed)

          
 

Draft 3
Frequency Response SAR

Draft SAR Version 3

Comment Period

Info>>

Submit Comments>>

 

02/08/07 - 03/09/07

(closed)

Comments Received>> Consideration of Comments>>
 

Draft 2
Frequency Response SAR

Draft SAR Version 2

Comment Period

Info>>

Submit Comments>>

 

04/04/06 - 05/03/06

(closed) 

 

Comments Received>> Consideration of Comments>>
 

Draft 1

Draft SAR Version 1

White Paper

 

01/17/05 - 02/17/05

(closed)

Comments Received>>

Consideration of Comments>>

All comments should be forwarded to sarcomm@nerc.net.