ATC/TTC/AFC and CBM/TRM Revisions

ATC/TTC/AFC and CBM/TRM Revisions (Project 2006-07)

Related Files

Status:
The drafting team is working on responding to the comments received from the VRF Analysis and Recommendations Report that was posted for a 21-day comment period ending on January 28, 2009.

The NERC Board of Trustees adopted the MOD-001, MOD-008, MOD-028, MOD-029, and MOD-030 standards during its August 26, 2008 conference call. The standards have been approved by FERC (MOD-001-1, MOD-008-1, MOD-028-1, MOD-029-1, MOD030-2). The Board has deferred action on the Violation Risk Factors for these standards, pending further analysis.

Purpose/Industry Need:
The ATC/TTC/AFC Revision SAR proposes changing MOD-001-0 by adding a requirement for transmission providers to coordinate the calculation of ATC and requires that specific reliability practices be incorporated into the ATC calculation and coordination methodologies. Such changes will enhance the reliable use of the transmission system without needlessly limiting commercial activity. This request adds a requirement for documentation of the methodologies used to coordinate ATC. In addition, a requirement is added for the enhanced documentation of the calculation methodology.

The CBM/TRM Revisions SAR proposes changing existing standards on TRM to require crisp and clear documentation of the calculation of TRM and make various components of the methodology mandatory so there is more consistency across methodologies.

MOD-030-2 Status:
The recirculation ballot results are posted below. The standard was approved and will be submitted to the NERC Board of Trustees for adoption

Purpose/Industry Need:
Requirements 2 and 11 of MOD-030-1 will be modified.

Proposed Standard	Supporting Material	Comment Period	Comments Received	Response to Comments
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM Posted for 10-day Recirculation Ballot Window MOD-030-2 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Implementation Plan	01/20/09 – 01/29/09 (closed) 10-day Recirculation Ballot		Announcement Ballot Results
Announcement ATC Violation Risk Factor Analysis and Recommendations Report for a 21-day comment period	VRF Analysis and Recommendations Report	01/07/09 - 01/28/09 (closed) Electronic Comment Form Word Version of Questions	Comments Received
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM Posted for 10-day Ballot Window MOD-030-2 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting		12/01/08–12/10/08 (closed) 10-day Ballot Window		Announcement Ballot Results Response to Comments
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM Posted for 30-day Pre-ballot Review and Join Ballot Pool MOD-030-2 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Implementation Plan	10/28/08–11/26/08 (closed) 30-day Pre-ballot Review and Join Ballot Pool
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM Posted for 10-day Recirculation Ballot Window MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	10/28/08–11/06/08 (closed) 10-day Recirculation Ballot		Announcement Ballot Results
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM Posted for 10-day Ballot Window MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	09/11/08 – 09/21/08 (closed) 10-day Ballot Window		Announcement Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM Posted for Board of Trustees Adoption August 22, 2008 MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-028-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	MOD-001-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-008-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-028-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-029-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-030-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CMB/TRM 10-day Recirculation Ballot Window MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-028 1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	MOD-001-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-008-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-028-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-029-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps MOD-030-1 Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps	08/12/08 – 08/21/08 (closed) Recirculation Ballot		Announcement Recirculation Ballot Results MOD-001-1 MOD-008-1 MOD-028-1 MOD-029-1 MOD-030-1
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM Posted for 30-day Pre-ballot Window and Ballot Pool MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	08/12/08 – 09/11/08 (closed) Pre-Ballot Window and Ballot Pool
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM Posted for 45-day Comment Period MOD-030-2 Clean \| Redline to recirculation version SAR Version 1	Implementation Plan	08/12/08 – 09/24/08 (closed) Electronic Comment Form Questions in Word Form	Comments	Response to Comments
Announcement ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM ― Project 2006-07 10-day Ballot Window July 21–July 30, 2008 (closed)
Announcement ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM ― Project 2006-07 30-day Pre-ballot Review June 20–July 21, 2008 (closed)
MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps			Initial Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps			Initial Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
MOD-028-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps			Initial Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps			Initial Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline Process Steps			Initial Ballot Results Ballot Comments Response to Comments
Announcement Project 2006-07 ― ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM Posted for 30-day Comment Period MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to Last Posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	05/23/08 – 06/23/08 (closed) Electronic Comment Form Comment Form in Word	Comments	Consideration of Comments
Announcement 30-day Comment Period for Project 2006-07 ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM April 16-May 15, 2008 (closed) NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.
MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Comment Form Word Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Comment Form Word Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-028-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Comment Form Word Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Comment Form Word Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting NOTE: NAESB is in the process of developing the ATC business practices related to transparency and other commercial issues, including postbacks. To view NAESB's current work, please go to http://naesb.org/weq/weq_atc_afc.asp.	Implementation Plan Clean \| Redline to Last Posting	Comment Form Word Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
Announcement Ballot Windows Project 2006-07 - ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM March 3-12, 2008 (closed)				Announcement Initial Ballot Results Link to Ballot Summary and Comments
MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
MOD-028-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan			Consideration of Comments
Announcement Pre-ballot Windows and Ballot Pools Open for Project 2006-07 ATC/TTC and CBM/TRM February 1-March 3, 2008 (closed)
MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
MOD-004-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
MOD-008-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
MOD-028-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
MOD-029-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
MOD-030-1 Clean \| Redline to last posting	Implementation Plan
Announcement Draft Available Transfer Capability Standards Posted for 45-day Comment Period		10/31/07 - 12/14/07 (closed) Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-001-1	Implementation Plan Summary of FERC Directives in FERC Orders 693 and 890 and Corresponding NERC Standards and Requirements
MOD-004-1
MOD-008-1
MOD-028-1
MOD-029-1 (revised)
MOD-030-1
Announcement Draft Available Transfer Capability Standards Posted for 30-day Comment Period May 25 through June 25, 2007 (closed)
MOD-001-1	White Paper Summary of Changes to the Structure of the Standards for ATC	Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-004-1		Comment Form Attachment 1	Comments	Consideration of Comments (revised)
MOD-008-1		Comment Form Attachment 1	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-028-1		Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-029-1		Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
MOD-030-1		Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
Final Supplemental ATC SAR Clean \| Redline to last posting
Announcement Supplemental ATC SAR		Comment Form Nomination Form 05/25/07 - 06/08/07 (closed)	Comments	Consideration of Comments
Announcement Draft 1 Standard MOD-001-1 Posted for 30-day Comment Period February 15 through March 16, 2007 MOD-001-1 Clean \| Redline to Version 0		02/15/07 - 03/16/07 (closed) Comment Form	Comments	Consideration of Comments
Final SAR: ATC/TTC/AFC Final SAR: CBM/TRM	CBM Minority Opinion
Draft SAR Version 1: ATC/TTC/AFC Revision Draft SAR Version 1: CBM/TRM Revision		07/08/05 - 08/08/05 (closed)	Comments	Responses
To download a file click on the file using your right mouse button, then save it to your computer in a directory of your choice.
Documents in the PDF format require use of the Adobe Reader® software. Free Adobe Reader® software allows anyone view and print Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) files. For more information download the Adobe Reader User Guide.

All comments should be forwarded to sarcomm@nerc.net.
Questions? Contact Lauren Koller - lauren.koller@nerc.net or 609-452-8060.

Legal and Privacy : 609.452.8060 voice : 609.452.9550 fax : 116-390 Village Boulevard : Princeton, NJ 08540-5721
Washington Office: 1120 G Street, N.W. : Suite 990 : Washington, DC 20005-3801

Copyright © 2008 by the North American Electric Reliability Corporation. : All rights reserved.
A New Jersey Nonprofit Corporation