search
  |    Account Log-In/Register    |    Contact Us
Project 2010-14.2.2 Phase 2 of Balancing Authority Reliability-based Controls - BAL-004-2

Related Files | Project 2007-05 - Balancing Authority Controls | Project 2007-18 - Reliability-based Control | Project 2010-14.2 – Periodic Review of BAL Standards


Status
A final ballot for the recommended retirement of BAL-004-0 – Time Error Correction concluded 8 p.m. Eastern, Thursday, December 17, 2015. The voting results can be accessed via the links below. The standard will be submitted to the Board of Trustees for adoption and then filed with the appropriate regulatory authorities.

Background
The BARC 2 PRT was appointed by the Standards Committee on September 19, 2013 as part of NERC’s obligation to conduct periodic reviews of its standards. The BARC 2 PRT used background information on the standards and the questions set forth in the Periodic Review Template developed by NERC and approved by the Standards Committee, along with associated worksheets and reference documents, to determine whether BAL-004-0 should be: (1) affirmed as is (i.e., no changes needed); (2) revised (which may include revising or retiring one or more requirements); or (3) retired. During the development of the recommendation, the PRT also considered stakeholder recommendations for candidate Paragraph 81 requirements from Phase 1 of Paragraph 81, and applied the Paragraph 81 criteria to all of the requirements. The team also considered the Independent Expert Review Panel recommendations on the two standards.

After an extensive review, the BARC 2 PRT is recommending that Reliability Standard BAL-004-0 be retired and that manual Time Error Correction (TEC) be eliminated as a continent-wide NERC requirement. Once the current 30-day industry comment period concludes, the BARC 2 SDT will consider comments and finalize its recommendation, which will be presented to the Standards Committee.

The Balancing Authority Reliability-based Controls 2.2 Standard Drafting Team (BARC 2.2 SDT) reviewed the findings of the BARC 2 Primary Review Team. A survey was posted for comment August 12-25, 2015 to gain a better perspective as to any concerns the industry may have if the practice of manual Time Error Correction (TEC) was eliminated. The survey responses indicated support for retirement of manual TEC as a standard. Upon further review the BARC 2.2 SDT determined that manual TEC would not support the reliability of the BPS. Conducting manual TEC in any form directly contradicts NERC Reliability Principle 2: “The frequency and voltage of interconnected bulk power systems shall be controlled within defined limits through the balancing of real and reactive power supply and demand.” The practice of using manual TEC to place the Interconnection closer to the settings for automatic underfrequency load shedding does not support or enhance reliability. Therefore, BAL-004-0 should be retired.

The survey responses also indicated that the accompanying North American Energy Standard Board (NAESB) WEQ Manual Time Error Correction Business Practice Standard – WEQ-006, should be retired contemporaneously with BAL-004-0. The BARC 2.2 SDT’s recommendation for retirement of BAL-004-0 is contingent on simultaneous retirement of NAESB WEQ-006 to ensure clarity and to avoid inadvertent, uncoordinated, manual TEC.  The BARC 2.2 SDT has been coordinating with NAESB on this issue. Upon retirement of BAL-004-0 and NAESB WEQ-006, currently or soon to be effective Reliability Standards BAL-003-1 and BAL-001-2 will incent continued adherence to a frequency approximating 60 Hz over long-term averages.

 
Standard(s) affected - BAL-004-0
 
Purpose/Industry Need:
N/A
 
Draft Actions Dates Results Consideration of Comments


BAL-004-0

White Paper


​Final Ballot

Info

Vote

​12/08/15 - 12/17/15 Summary

Ballot Results​


BAL-004-0

Due to the recommended retirement/extensive changes, a redline of BAL-004 is not included

Implementation Plan

Supporting Materials

Unofficial Comment Form

White Paper


Initial Ballot

Updated Info

Info

Vote

11/03/15 - 11/12/15​ Summary

Ballot Results​

Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments​

09/24/15 - 11/12/15​ Comments Received Consideration of Comments

Join Ballot Pool
09/24/15 - 10/23/15​


Time Error Correction Requirements

Supporting Materials
Unofficial Survey Form (Word)

​Survey Period

Info

Submit Responses
​08/12/15 - 08/25/15 Comments Received​ ​Consideration of Comments

Unofficial Nomination Form (Word)


​Supplemental Nomination Period

Info

Submit Nomination
 

​05/21/15 - 06/01/15
Supporting Materials
 
 
Comment Period

Info

Submit Comments
03/17/15 - 04/15/15 Comments Received Consideration of Comments
Nomination Period
Submit Nomination
​03/17/15 - 03/26/15
 

 

 
 

home | account log-in/register | legal and privacy/trademark policy | site map | careers | contact us

Atlanta Office | 3353 Peachtree Road, NE Suite 600 North Tower, Atlanta, GA 30326 | 404-446-2560
Washington Office | 1325 G Street, NW Suite 600, Washington, DC 20005| 202-400-3000

Copyright 2016 North American Electric Reliability Corporation. All rights reserved.