Regions | Committees | Meetings | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Home

Regional Reliability Standards

Reliability Standards Home | Regional Reliability Standards Home

 Comments on Regional Standards Development Procedures

Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures define the process for development, revision, reaffirmation, and withdrawal of regional reliability standards by a regional entity (ERCOT, FRCC, MRO, NPCC, RFC, SERC, SPP, and WECC).  Regional reliability standards shall provide for as much uniformity as possible with reliability standards across the interconnected bulk power system of the North American continent.  Regional reliability standards, when approved by FERC and applicable authorities in Mexico and Canada shall be made part of the body of NERC reliability standards and shall be enforced upon all applicable bulk power system owners, operators, and users within the applicable area, regardless of membership in the region.

The approval process for a regional reliability standards development procedure requires NERC to publicly notice and request comment on the proposed procedure. Evaluation of the proposed procedure shall identify whether or not a proposed regional reliability standards development procedure meets the criteria listed below. Each regional reliability standards development procedure shall be:

  • Open — The regional reliability standards development procedure shall provide that any person or entity who is directly and materially affected by the reliability of the bulk power systems within the regional entity shall be able to participate in the development and approval of reliability standards. There shall be no undue financial barriers to participation. Participation shall not be conditional upon membership in the regional entity, a regional entity or any organization, and shall not be unreasonably restricted on the basis of technical qualifications or other such requirements.

  • Inclusive — The regional reliability standards development procedure shall provide that any person with a direct and material interest has a right to participate by expressing an opinion and its basis, having that position considered, and appealing through an established appeals process if adversely affected.

  • Balanced — The regional reliability standards development procedure shall have a balance of interests and shall not be dominated by any two interest categories and no single interest category shall be able to defeat a matter.

  • Due Process — The regional reliability standards development procedure shall provide for reasonable notice and opportunity for public comment. At a minimum, the procedure shall include public notice of the intent to develop a standard, a public comment period on the proposed standard, due consideration of those public comments, and a ballot of interested stakeholders.

  • Transparent — All actions material to the development of regional reliability standards shall be transparent. All standards development meetings shall be open and publicly noticed on the regional entity’s Web site.

 

Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures
File Type Size Date Description
 ERCOT
 ERCOT Posting of 9/20/06-10/21/06
 Acrobat 123 KB 09/20/06

Texas Regional Entity Standards Development Process
Exhibit C to the Delegation Agreement Between NERC and ERCOT

 Comments from 9/20/06-10/21/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/24/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 ERCOT Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/21/06 Posting

Acrobat 24 KB 11/14/06

ERCOT Response

FRCC
FRCC Posting of 9/7/07-9/21/07
Word 167 KB 09/07/07 FRCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures Comment Form
Acrobat 133 KB 09/07/07 FRCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (clean)
Acrobat 113 KB 09/07/07 FRCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (redline)
Acrobat 31 KB 09/07/07 FRCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure Submittal Request

 Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

       

 FRCC Response to Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

     

 

 FRCC Posting of 9/20/06-10/21/06
 Acrobat 77 KB 09/20/06

FRCC Regional Reliability Standard Development Process Manual

 Comments from 9/20/06-10/21/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/24/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 FRCC Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/21/06 Posting

Acrobat 29 KB 11/21/06

FRCC Response

MRO
 MRO Posting of 9/21/06-10/21/06
 Acrobat 214 KB 09/21/06

Midwest Reliability Organization Reliability Standards Process Manual

 Comments from 9/21/06-10/21/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/24/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 MRO Response to Comments from 9/21/06-10/21/06 Posting

Acrobat 36 KB 11/14/06

MRO Response

NPCC
NPCC Posting of 9/7/07-9/21/07
Word 160 KB 09/07/07 NPCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures Comment Form
Acrobat 218 KB 09/07/07 NPCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (clean)
Acrobat 241 KB 09/07/07 NPCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (redline)
Acrobat 31 KB 09/07/07 NPCC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure Submittal Request
Acrobat 41 KB 09/10/07

NPCC Regional Standards Development Procedure Announcement

 Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

Acrobat 518 KB 09/26/07 Rick White - Northeast Utilities

 NPCC Response to Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

Acrobat 29 KB 09/28/07

NPCC Response

 NPCC Posting of 9/20/06-10/20/06
 Acrobat 228 KB 09/20/06

Northeast Power Coordinating Council: Cross-Border Regional Entity, Inc. (NPCC CBRE)

Draft Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure

 Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

E. Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/24/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 NPCC Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 33 KB 11/07/06

NPCC Response

RFC
 RFC Posting of 8/28/07-09/27/07
Word 174 KB 08/28/07 RFC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures Comment Form
Acrobat 160 KB 08/28/07 RFC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (clean)
Acrobat 121 KB 08/28/07 RFC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (redline)
Acrobat 36 KB 08/28/07

RFC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure Submittal Request

Acrobat 60 KB 08/28/07 Comments & Responses Received from 1st Posting 7/16/07-8/14/07 on RFC Website

 Comments from 8/28/07-09/27/07 Posting

      No comments received.

 RFC Response to Comments from 8/28/07-09/27/07 Posting

      No comments received.
 RFC Posting of 9/20/06-10/20/06
Acrobat 92 KB 09/20/06

DRAFT ReliabilityFirst Corporation Reliability Standards Development Procedure

 Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 36 KB 10/13/06

K. Kohlrus - City Water, Light & Power

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 RFC Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 33 KB 11/14/06 RFC Response
SERC
SERC Posting of 8/2/07-9/4/07
Word 170 KB 08/02/07 SERC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures Comment Form
Acrobat 274 KB 08/02/07 SERC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (clean)
Acrobat 267 KB 08/02/07 SERC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (redline)
Acrobat 34 KB 08/02/07 SERC Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure Submittal Request

 Comments from 8/2/07-9/4/07 Posting

Acrobat 67 KB 09/04/07 PJM - Mark Kuras
Acrobat 67 KB 08/23/07 Public Service Commission of South Carolina - Phil Riley
Acrobat 66 KB 08/15/07 Michael Puscas - United Illuminating

 SERC Response to Comments from 8/2/07-9/4/07 Posting

Acrobat 60 KB 10/18/07

SERC Response

SERC Posting of 9/20/06-10/20/06
 Acrobat 113 KB 09/20/06

SERC Regional Reliability Standard Development Procedure

Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 36 KB 10/13/06

K. Kohlrus - City Water, Light & Power

 Acrobat 37 KB 10/20/06

R. McGarrah - Ameren

Acrobat 48 KB 10/20/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 SERC Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 31 KB 11/17/06

SERC Response

SPP
SPP Posting of 9/7/07-9/21/07
Word 174 KB 09/07/07 SPP Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedures Comment Form
Acrobat 107 KB 09/07/07 SPP Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (clean)
Acrobat 143 KB 09/07/07 SPP Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure (redline)
Acrobat 39 KB 09/07/07 SPP Regional Reliability Standards Development Procedure Submittal Request

 Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

Acrobat 82 KB 09/26/07 Terri Eaton - Xcel Energy

 SPP Response to Comments from 9/7/07-9/21/07 Posting

     

 

 SPP Posting of 9/21/06-10/21/06
 Acrobat 556 KB 09/21/06

Southwest Power Pool Regional Entity Standards Development Process Manual

Comments from 9/21/06-10/21/06 Posting

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/20/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 SPP Response to Comments from 9/21/06 Posting

Acrobat 28 KB 11/20/06

SPP Response

WECC
 WECC Posting of 9/20/06-10/20/06
Acrobat 56 KB 09/20/06

Process for Developing and Approving WECC Standards

 Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 31 KB 10/02/06

K. Bryan - US Army Corps of Engineers

 Acrobat 82 KB 10/24/06

Edward Dahill - National Grid

Acrobat 48 KB 10/20/06

J. Cyrulewski - JDRJC Associates

Acrobat 40 KB 10/20/06

Dave Folk - FirstEnergy Corp.

 WECC Response to Comments from 9/20/06-10/20/06 Posting

Acrobat 33 KB 12/05/06 WECC Response
To download a file click on the file using your right mouse button, then save it to your computer in a directory of your choice.

Documents in the PDF format require use of the Adobe Reader® software.  Free Adobe Reader® software allows anyone view and print Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) files.   For more information download the Adobe Reader User Guide.


Copyright