Regions | Committees | Meetings | Search | Site Map | Contact Us | Home

Reliability Standards

 

Transmission Relay Loadability

Registered Ballot Body | Related Files | Reliability Standards Home Page | Drafting Team Rosters

Status
The Relay Loadability Standard Drafting Team is considering the comments received from the posting of the "Determination and Application of Practical Relaying Loadability Ratings" reference document.

Purpose/Industry Need
This proposed standard will address the cascading transmission outages that occurred in the August 2003 blackout when backup distance and phase relays operated on high loading and low voltage without electrical faults on the protected lines.  This is the so-called ‘zone 3 relay’ issue, which has been expanded to address other protection devices subject to unintended operation during extreme system conditions.  The standard will establish minimum loadability criteria for these relays to minimize the chance of unnecessary line trips during a major system disturbance.  In December 2005, the Planning Committee approved a white paper providing the engineering basis for the proposed standard, culminating a major project to analyze the performance of existing protection systems and to research preferred set points.
 
Proposed Standard Supporting Materials Comment 
Period
Comments 
Received

Response 
to Comments

 

Announcement

Relay Loadability Reference Document
Posted for 45-day Comment Period

Reference Document

03/20/08 - 05/03/08
(closed)

Comment Form

Questions

Comments  

Draft 5
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 
Board of Trustees Approval

PRC-023-1
Clean | Redline to initial ballot

Implementation Plan

Reference Document

     

Announcement

Draft 5
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 10-day Ballot Recirculation Ballot Window

PRC-023-1
Clean | Redline to initial ballot

Implementation Plan

Reference Document

01/31/08 - 02/09/08

Recirculation Ballot Window

 

Announcement

Ballot Summary

Announcement

Draft 4
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 10-day Ballot Window

Clean | Redline to last posting

Implementation Plan

Clean | Redline to last posting

Reference Document

11/19/07 - 12/04/07
(closed)

10-day Ballot Window

 

Announcement

Ballot Summary

Consideration of Comments

Announcement

Draft 4
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 30-day Pre-ballot Review

Clean | Redline to last posting

Implementation Plan

Clean | Redline to last posting

Reference Document

10/18/07 - 11/19/07
(closed)

Pre-ballot Review

   

Announcement

Draft 3
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 30-day Comment Period
March 19 through April 17, 2007

Clean | Redline to last posting

Implementation Plan
Clean | Redline
03/19/07 - 04/17/07

Comment Form

Comments Consideration of Comments

Revised

Announcement

Draft 2
Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 30-day Comment Period
January 9 through February 7, 2007

Clean | Redline to first posting

Implementation Plan
Clean | Redline

Relay Loadability Reference

Comment Form

 12/09/07 - 02/07/07 (Ended)

Comments Consideration of Comments

Announcement

Draft 1

Relay Loadability Standard
Posted for 45-day Comment Period
August 16 through September 29, 2006

Draft Standard Version 1

Implementation Plan

Reference Document

Comment Form

08/16/06 - 09/29/06 (Ended)

Comments Consideration of Comments

Draft 2

Draft SAR Version 2 - clean

Draft SAR Version 2 - redline

       

Announcement

Solicit Drafting Team Members

  Nomination Form
Due May 3, 2006
   

Announcement

Draft 1
Posted for Comment
January 16-February 15, 2006

Draft SAR Version 1

Working Paper on
Proposed Transmission
Relay Loadability
January 16, 2006 - February 15, 2006

Nomination Form
Due February 3, 2006

Comments Responses
To download a file click on the file using your right mouse button, then save it to your computer in a directory of your choice.

Documents in the PDF format require use of the Adobe Reader® software.  Free Adobe Reader® software allows anyone view and print Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF) files.   For more information download the Adobe Reader User Guide.


All comments should be forwarded to sarcomm@nerc.net.  
Questions?  Contact Barbara Bogenrief - barbara.bogenrief@nerc.net or 609-452-8060.


Copyright